Machine Transcription vs Human Transcriber: Why Machine Transcription Will Never Replace Human Transcribers?

  • Home
  • Transcriptions
  • Machine Transcription vs Human Transcriber: Why Machine Transcription Will Never Replace Human Transcribers?

The fight between humans and machines is never-ending.

Thus, ‘machine transcription vs human transcription’ is the biggest topic of today; and with time passing by, it is just getting more intense.

No wonder, technology has blessed us with n number of advantages. But, it has a dark side too, that is often neglected by modern entrepreneurs.

Honestly speaking, business owners should not be blamed for this.

When we look at both options, they appear to be quite similar on the surface. Hence, due to a lack of awareness or knowledge, they choose the former. They forget to look deep inside the options and compare the two, on the basis of their characteristics.

Many studies have been conducted on finding the right option between the two. As per the outcomes, it has been detected that machine transcriptions can never replace human transcription.

The reasons behind this are very simple, yet difficult to understand. Hence, get all your focus here and find out the top reasons why humans are better than any automated technology –

Why a Transcribe Machine Cannot Replace Human Transcribers

There are many reasons behind it, and those are as followed:

1. Accuracy:

A transcribe machine is no anymore capable to come across even half-done the accuracy that a well-trained person can easily able to do it.

There are several devices, no matter how those are innovative in technology they are, that cannot go beyond the precision in transcription that experts can simply perform.

That is why most of the biggest firms and data hubs still take the services of a reliable local transcription company near you when it comes to recording their important assignments.

2. Time Involved

The time involved in transcription via machine is lesser than that of human. Since it is a machine, it can perform the task within a few seconds. However, you cannot be confirmed its quality. Humans do take time in transcription.

But, they deliver it in high quality on the very first attempt. You need not invest your time, money, and other resources in sending it for re-correction, several times.

Also, it should be noted that the project is delivered within a proposed time frame. So, if you weigh quality more than quantity, then there are more crucial benefits of transcription company than machine transcription.

3. Create Senseful Sentences

In this way, these automatic tools cannot truly know a variety of languages and their construction, grammar instructions, and transcript generally.

While they computerize transcripts, they are not as successful as other humans in comprehending the actual domain dialectal.

Experts can take a decision on the accuracy of the content that makes sense but a mechanical device cannot do that.

4. Subject Matter Expertise

Transcription is majorly demanded in legal, media, and medical industries, which require high-quality output.

Thus, in this case, as well, human expertise is better than machine programming. A human transcriber possesses years of knowledge and talent in working for the said industry.

Also, he gets trained in accurate audio transcription for the specific sector, whereas, machines lack all of such attributes.

Machines do not understand the very basic nature of legal, media, and medical industries. So, how will they end up with an accurate output?

5. Ability To Read the Texts

The devices cannot anyhow substitute beings in all parts of the task. However, machines do not have the ability to read texts, and also they are automated by people.

Hence, the information they hold when it approaches the instructions and guiding principle in transcriptions, are not adequate for a human that can inform himself of the newest styles and practice in transliterating. People can perceive the sound and can read the contents properly, but a mechanical device cannot do this thing at all.

Thus, software for premium business transcription may turn out not the effective medium for understanding the acoustic to record, particularly in complex jobs, like pharmaceutical and law texts.

6. Accent & Multiple Speakers

There may be some audio files, which contain multiple accents or speakers. This makes it difficult for a machine to recognize different voices or accents spoken by the people involved in the audio file.

Also, the flow of information exchanged among the people in the audio, might be too much to handle, for a machine. Sometimes, the background noise may also be a hurdle for a machine to detect what’s being spoken.

However, none of these is a challenge to a human transcriber who can offer popular types of transcription.

No matter, how tough the audio is, in terms of a number of speakers, background noise, industry jargon, etc., human talent will never let you down.

7. Understand The Connotation of the Manuscript

Professionals can easily understand the connotation of the manuscript that they decode. In this situation, the clients don’t need to worry anymore, because their assignments will comprise mistakes in the transcript.

Without expressing anything, specialists can perform their dictation work correctly, mainly in terms of editing tasks, and it is not what a machine can do.

Humans can comprehend dialogue configurations and devices are unable to do it.

8. Punctuation and Grammar

Although the machine would be programmed perfectly for grammar and punctuation rules, the quality delivered by any human providing credible voice to text transcription would be higher than that by the machine.

The audio generally constitutes conversation between two or more people, and while sharing their ideas, they may take pauses, to take a sip of coffee or just recollect their thoughts, etc.

So, how would a computer get to know what was the pause for?

It might mistake the pause to be a pause taken at the end of a paragraph or a sentence. Hence, the whole meaning would change.

9. Correct Structure

Machinery tools for transcripts cannot understand the formats of the transcribed contents, unlike humans.

The proper and correct structure of the contents that can be done correctly by skilled people, can’t be done by some tools.

Humans can initiate the actual roles of transcription.

10. Dictation

When it comes to computerized or robot tools for recording voices then we may always find that diction cannot be fully completed by devices. But in the opposite case, humans can better understand the words and their entire sentence frames and can convert them properly into other dialects.

Both automated technology and human transcription have advantages of their own. However, if you are looking for high-quality output, you should always vouch for human talent.

Accuracy, speed, time efficiency, and everything else favors human expertise more than machine programming. Hence, next time, you invest in transcription, do consider these points and make the right decision.

Technology is not bad. It is created just to make things easier for us. But, when it comes to top types of business transcription, you cannot afford to make mistakes; and machines do commit mistakes in the language world.

In A Nutshell:

Many companies want to save on business budgets by hiring specialists to transcribe their audio and video texts. Well-experienced staffs of transcription firms are a practical strength for industries. Thus, if you are searching for well-experienced, human transcribers, reach Tridindia. With a team of highly-qualified and skilled transcription specialists, we have satisfied many clients and helped them grow.

To know more about our services call us at +91-8527599523 or grab an instant quote now.

Never miss a story..!!

Grab the Latest Translation and language News, Tips, Updates & Trends..!!

[email-subscribers namefield=”NO” group=”Public”]
See Our Knowledge Center